Statement to be judged: "Judgment J11 was illegal: the judgment should have been 'false'."

Judgment: True.

Judge's reasons:

deced: TRUE My reasons are themink's reasons. They persuade me. The implied distinction between a "selected Proposal" and a "current" Proposal in Rule 331 seems the clincher. But his argument from game custom bolsters this position even more securely.

Mr Coxy: TRUE In light of theminks well argued case, which hinges on a rule that I had not fully appreciated

Elden: TRUE based on the arguments already provided by themink

Starfighter Pilot: TRUE

Challenges:

Judgment called by: themink

Judge selected at: 17/06/07 21:24 GMT

Judges: deced, Elden, Mr Coxy, Starfighter Pilot