Statement to be judged: "It is not permitted for a Player to give Oranges to other Players except in ways defined by the Rules."

Judgment: True

Judge's reasons: Bearing in mind that:

1. The Rules are unclear. Of course.
2. Elden declined the Oranges anyway.
3. This Game's probably going to end soon.
4. Mr Coxy's interpretation of Rule 113 would set a precedent for taking actions not specifically covered in the Rules, some of which could be detrimental to the Game.

I judge the statement to be true, and urge somebody to make a Proposal clarifying the meaning of 'regulated'.

Challenges: None.

Judgment called by: deced

Judge: Llama Roddy

Judgment called at: 01/03/07 23:52 GMT

Judgment delivered at: 02/03/07 19:02 GMT